AirNewsTimes Uk About US Contact

Malaysia Airlines plane crash in Ukraine

Malaysia Airlines plane crash in Ukraine

Time after time, the pro-Russian guerrillas in eastern Ukraine have shown their ability to shoot down aircraft.

» Aircraft Accidents | Saturday, July 19, 2014 • Telegraph
In the last four days alone, two Ukrainian military planes have been destroyed - an SU-25 ground attack fighter, which was brought down on Wednesday, and an AN-26 transport aircraft, which fell from the sky on Monday. Last month, an IL-76 freighter was set ablaze as it came in to land at Luhansk airport.

All of these aircraft - along with numerous helicopters - fell victim to surface-to-air missiles. The SU-25 was destroyed so close to the Russian frontier that Ukraine's government claims the fatal weapon was actually launched from inside its neighbour.

If Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 was brought down by a missile, then the finger of suspicion would point towards the pro-Russian rebels. Put bluntly, they are the only side in Ukraine's conflict which has been shooting down aircraft on a regular basis for several months.
 
There is little doubt over where the weapons come from. Russia has been arming the insurgents ever since the crisis in eastern Ukraine began in April.

That support has gone beyond the supply of small arms: in addition to surface-to-air missiles, the rebels have also shown that they possess main battle tanks, apparently obtained from Russian stockpiles just across the border.

But that still leaves one vital question. The shoulder-launched missiles used by the rebels are capable of destroying aircraft flying at relatively low altitudes. These weapons are generally effective up to about 10,000 feet. The downed Ukrainian planes were hit at relatively low altitudes, notably when they were trying to land.

Yet the publicly available radar records show that Flight MH17 was flying at 33,000 feet, well beyond the reach of shoulder-launched weapons. Destroying an aircraft at that height would almost certainly require a radar-guided surface-to-air missile fired from a ground battery.

There is no evidence that Russia has entrusted weaponry of that kind to the insurgents, nor that they would have the skill to use systems of such complexity.

That leaves two possibilities: Flight MH17 could have been destroyed by a missile launched from the Russian side of the frontier, possibly after being mistaken for a Ukrainian military transport aircraft.

Alternatively, Ukraine's own forces might have made a terrible error. Back in 2001, Ukraine admitted destroying a civil airliner by mistake, killing 78 passengers and crew, when its forces were testing an S-200 surface-to-air missile.

For months, Ukraine and Russia have been waging an undeclared war. Both sides will have raised the alert level of their respective air defences. If MH17 was destroyed by a missile, the chances are that either Russia or Ukraine mistook the Malaysian plane for a hostile aircraft - and acted accordingly.
Warning: Comments which include insulting, offensive sentences or hints, assault and comments with the unwritten rules of spellingand written in English characters incorrectly will not be approved.
Login to make a comment with your user name
Yorumunuzu Sendin
Tüm Yorumları Okumak İçin tıklayın

More News

All Nippon Airways Reportedly to Order the Airbus A380
Thursday, December 31, 2015    
AA550: Interview With First Officer Steve Stackelhouse
Thursday, December 31, 2015    
Qantas Resumes Nonstop Service to San Francisco
Thursday, December 31, 2015    
AirwaysNews' 2015 Top 10 Stories
Wednesday, December 30, 2015    
First A320neo Delivery Postponed Until January
Wednesday, December 30, 2015    
Most Significant Aviation Events in 2015
Tuesday, December 29, 2015    
Op-Ed: Is Open Seating Losing Altitude at Southwest?
Tuesday, December 29, 2015    
AirwaysNews' 2016 Aviation Predictions
Monday, December 28, 2015    
Top 10 Holiday Videos
Thursday, December 24, 2015    
The 2015 AirwaysNews Aviation Holiday Wish List
Wednesday, December 23, 2015    
Airbus Beluga XL Production Starts
Monday, December 21, 2015    
Airbus to Delay IndiGo's A320neo Delivery
Monday, December 21, 2015    
WestJet Spreads Holiday Cheer 12,000 Times
Monday, December 21, 2015    
Flashback Friday: 80th Anniversary of the Douglas DC-3
Saturday, December 19, 2015    
All Nippon Airways Reportedly to Order the Airbus A380
All Nippon Airways Reportedly to Order the Airbus A380
ANA is reportedly planning to order three Airbus A380s, according to Nikkei
EVA Airways Becomes a Boeing 787-10 Customer
EVA Airways Becomes a Boeing 787-10 Customer
The Taiwanese Carrier has inked a deal with Boeing for the purchase of up o
Delta to Keep 14 Additional Boeing 757-200s
Delta to Keep 14 Additional Boeing 757-200s
According to Bloomberg, Delta will keep 14 Boeing 757-200 aircraft that wer
Bombardier: CSeries Certification Program on Track
Bombardier: CSeries Certification Program on Track
Despite the shadows about its future, Bombardier stays loyal to its CSeries
CityJet to Take Delivery of 15 Superjet SSJ100
CityJet to Take Delivery of 15 Superjet SSJ100
CityJet has confirmed today the acquisition of 15 SuperJet SSj100, with del
CityJet to Become a CRJ-900 Operator
CityJet to Become a CRJ-900 Operator
Irish carrier Cityjet has confirmed that will become a Bombardier CRJ-900 o
JetBlue to Take Off to Quito, Ecuador
JetBlue to Take Off to Quito, Ecuador
JetBlue continues its Latin American expansion out of Fort Lauderdale, now
  • Kara Kutu

  • Çok Okunan

  • Yorumlanan

AirNews'i Delicious'ta PaylaşınAirNews'i Stumbleupon'da Paylaşın!AirNews'i Twitter'da Takip Edin!AirNews Facebook Sayfasını Ziyaret EdinAirNews RSS
UK News | World | Aviation | Airlines | Airports | Business | Space | Technology | Tourism | Photos | Videos

This Site All Rights Reserved. Not be quoted without permission.

Copyright © 2008 - 2011 airnewstimes.co.uk

Design / Software: Air News Times